Fellow Streamers review the bone-chilling true crime documentary about Juana Barraza that will leave you questioning the depths of human darkness. Netflix has just released “The Lady of Silence, The Mataviejitas Murders,” a gripping journey into the twisted mind of one of the few Mexico serial killers. Spoilers Alert*
“The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders.”
This riveting true crime documentary unveils the haunting tale of Juana Barraza, a former professional wrestler turned notorious Mexican serial killer.
Netflix’s latest offering delves deep into the horrifying spate of murders that struck fear into Mexico City’s elderly population in the early noughties.
With an enigmatic killer on the loose, preying on older women in their own homes, terror gripped the city, and the nation demanded justice.
This meticulously crafted documentary, “The Lady of Silence,” takes you on a relentless pursuit to unravel the complexities of Juana Barraza’s dark past.
From her troubled upbringing in a rural area north of Mexico City to her unlikely career in the world of lucha libre, the stage is set for a chilling exploration of the mind behind the murders.
As the body count rose, Mexico City’s Attorney General’s Office faced an unprecedented challenge – capturing the elusive serial killer.
Witness descriptions of a tall, robust, and strong suspect posing as a nurse or government official to gain her victims’ trust added to the investigation’s complexity.
Join us as we peel back the layers of Juana Barraza’s life, discovering her unlikely association with Santa Muerte, a folk saint often associated with death.
This revelation sheds light on her motivations and the psychological factors that led to her reign of terror.
Netflix’s “The Lady of Silence” is not just a recounting of a series of gruesome crimes; it is an intimate exploration of the mind of a killer, her troubled past, and the impact of her actions on an entire society.
The documentary confronts questions of morality, justice, and the capacity for evil lurking within us all.
Prepare to be both fascinated and disturbed as we journey into the heart of darkness with “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders,” now streaming exclusively on Netflix.
Viewer discretion is advised as the documentary contains graphic content and sensitive subject matter.
Juana Barraza, born on December 27, 1957, is a Mexican serial killer who gained notoriety as “The Little Old Ladykiller” (La Mataviejitas in Spanish).
She was convicted and sentenced to 759 years in prison for killing 16 elderly women.
The first murder attributed to her has been dated variously to the late 1990s and to a specific killing on November 17, 2003.
However, it is believed that she may be responsible for more than 40 murders.
Barraza was born in Epazoyucan, Hidalgo, a rural area north of Mexico City, and her early life was marked by hardship and tragedy. She had a difficult upbringing, as her mother was an alcoholic who reportedly exchanged her for three beers, and she faced repeated abuse and trauma.
Despite her troubled past, Barraza developed an interest in lucha libre, the famous Mexican masked professional wrestling, and pursued a career as a professional wrestler under the ring name “La Dama del Silencio” (The Lady of Silence).
All of Barraza’s victims were women aged 60 or over, many of whom lived alone.
Her modus operandi involved bludgeoning or strangling them before robbing their homes.
The authorities initially struggled to identify and apprehend the killer, leading to nationwide outrage and extensive media coverage.
Barraza’s arrest finally came on January 25, 2006, after she was caught fleeing from the home of one of her victims.
To the surprise of many, including law enforcement, the suspect detained was a female wrestler known professionally as The Silent Lady – Juana Barraza.
Fingerprint evidence linked her to at least ten murders, and she confessed to four, denying involvement in all others.
Throughout her trial, it became evident that Barraza associated her elderly victims with her mother and believed that she was helping society by killing them.
Check out another Chilling true crime documentary, fellow streamer review: NETFLIX’S THE GOOD NURSE REVIEW (FILM AND DOCUMENTARY)
She posed as a government official or nurse to gain their trust before committing the heinous acts.
This psychological aspect placed her in the “care-giving” category of female killers.
Juana Barraza’s life and crimes continue to captivate the public’s imagination. Her dark past as a wrestler and her affiliation with Santa Muerte, a controversial figure in Mexican folklore, add layers of intrigue to her story.
The impact of her crimes and the haunting legacy of her actions remain etched in the memories of those who lived through the terror she unleashed on Mexico City.
The last Serial Killer in Mexico was in the 1950’s
The Mataviejitas Murders struck fear into the hearts of Mexico City’s elderly population. Victims were women aged 60 or over, many of whom lived alone.
Barraza’s modus operandi involved bludgeoning or strangling them before robbing their homes, leaving behind a trail of fear and devastation.
With the body count rising to over forty, Mexico City’s Attorney General’s Office faced an immense challenge – capturing the elusive serial killer.
Witnesses described a suspect who appeared tall, robust, and strong, cunningly posing as a nurse or government official to gain the trust of her victims.
The nationwide outrage and extensive media coverage added to the pressure of catching Mexico’s first serial killer.
Bernardo Bátiz, the chief prosecutor in Mexico City, initially profiled the killer as having “a brilliant mind, [being] quite clever and careful.”
Investigating officers suspected that the killer posed as a government official, offering victims the chance to sign up for welfare programs.
The search for Barraza was complicated by conflicting evidence. At one point, the police hypothesized that two killers might be involved.
An odd coincidence also distracted the investigation: at least three of Barraza’s victims owned a print of an eighteenth-century painting by French artist Jean-Baptiste Greuze, “Boy in A Red Waistcoat.”
Despite mounting evidence suggesting a serial killer was at work in Mexico City, the media criticized the authorities for dismissing it as “media sensationalism” until late 2005.
The police faced further criticism for conducting an unproductive swoop on the city’s transvestite prostitutes.
“The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” delves into Juana Barraza’s life, revealing her unlikely background as a former professional wrestler.
Wrestling became an escape for Barraza, providing a sense of empowerment and strength in a male-dominated sport.
However, her wrestling career did not lead to the fame and fortune she hoped for, leaving her disillusioned and struggling to make a living.
As the documentary explores her life story, we learn about Barraza’s connection with Santa Muerte, a folk saint often associated with death.
This controversial affiliation adds layers of intrigue to Barraza’s motivations and the psychological factors behind her crimes.
The authorities believed that Juana Barraza was a psychopath who felt no remorse.
Furthermore, Barraza associated her elderly victims with her mother and believed that she was helping society by killing them.
In order to gain the trust of her victims, Barraza posed as a government official who worked in social welfare.
Because of this, Barraza is placed in the “caregiving” category of female killers.
A major breakthrough in the case occurred on 25 January 2006 when a suspect was arrested fleeing from the home of the serial killer’s latest victim, Ana María de los Reyes Alfaro, an 82-year-old woman who had been strangled with a stethoscope.
To the surprise of many Mexicans, who had supposed the killer to be male, the suspect detained was Juana Barraza, a 48-year-old female wrestler known professionally as The Silent Lady.
Mexico City prosecutors said fingerprint evidence linked Barraza to at least ten murders of the as many as 40 murders attributed to the killer.
A Sentence for the Ages
The wrestler is said to have confessed to murdering Alfaro and three other women but denied involvement in all other killings.
Barraza was eventually sentenced to 759 years in prison for killing 16 elderly women, and the case of the Mataviejitas was officially closed.
However, more than 30 unresolved cases leave a lingering sense of injustice for the victims’ families.
As a Mexican living in the country during the time of the events, watching “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” on Netflix was an eye-opening experience that brought back haunting memories of those scary days.
The documentary’s meticulous attention to detail and careful approach to the sensitive subject made it a riveting and thought-provoking journey into the heart of one of Mexico’s most notorious criminal cases.
Documentary director María José Cuevas deserves immense credit for her skillful handling of such a sensational and tragic story.
She steers clear of sensationalism and avoids getting tripped up by the salacious nature of the murders, which had dominated the media at the time and left a lasting mark on Mexican pop culture.
Instead, Cuevas dives deep into the complexities of Juana Barraza’s life, unravelling the enigma of a former wrestler turned serial killer with a chilling focus on her psychological motivations.
Cuevas’ bio as a director reflects her dedication to unearthing compelling and thought-provoking stories.
She has a remarkable track record of shedding light on significant issues in Mexican society, often with a focus on women’s experiences and marginalized communities.
In “The Lady of Silence,” her adept storytelling skills allow viewers to confront the darkest aspects of humanity while humanizing both the victims and the perpetrator.
Cuevas’ storytelling prowess is evident as she crafts a narrative that captivates audiences and immerses them in the chilling atmosphere of Mexico City during those terrifying times.
“The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” stands as a five-star recommendation for true crime enthusiasts and those intrigued by the human psyche.
This engrossing documentary takes a deep dive into the mind of Juana Barraza, leaving viewers with lingering questions about the complexities of evil and the fine line between right and wrong.
As a Mexican who lived through those troubling times, I can attest that Cuevas’ work captures the essence of the fear and uncertainty that gripped the nation while also offering a glimpse into the resilience of the Mexican people.
In conclusion, Netflix’s “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” is a masterfully crafted true crime documentary that sets a new standard for exploring the depths of human darkness.
María José Cuevas’ directorial expertise shines through, providing a balanced and insightful perspective on a case that deeply impacted Mexican society.
A five-star recommendation, this gripping documentary should not be missed.
Stream now on Netflix.
Visit our home page for more reviews: Fellow Streamer